Skip to content
← Blog

The Best Project Management Software for Agencies of 10–50 People

What should a 20-person agency use to run projects? Five tools compared on what agencies actually need: time, budgets, capacity and client approvals.

Paul · · 3 min read

What should a 20-person agency use to run projects? If you bill time and need to see profit per project, start with an agency-specific tool like Productive or Teamwork. If you mainly need tasks and approvals to flow, ClickUp or Monday.com will do it with less change. Asana is the cleanest for pure task management but the lightest on agency finances.

The right answer depends on one question most comparisons skip: do you want your project tool to know about money?

What an agency needs that other teams don't

A product team needs tasks. An agency of 10–50 people needs tasks plus four things that decide whether a project makes money:

  • Time against budget, per project and per phase, while the project is still running.
  • Capacity: who is free next week, and who is booked past 100%.
  • Scope: a way to log and price change requests. See how to stop scope creep.
  • Client approvals that don't live in someone's inbox.

The five tools, compared

Built forTime and budgetsCapacity planningLearning curve
ProductiveAgencies and consultanciesCore feature: budgets, time, profitability, invoicingBuilt inMedium
Teamwork.comClient-services teamsStrong: time tracking and billingBuilt inMedium
ClickUpAny team, highly configurableTime built in; budgets need setupWorkload viewsHigh
Monday.comAny team, visual boardsLight; often paired with a time toolWorkload views on higher plansLow
AsanaTask and project managementLightWorkload views on higher plansLow
Our summary for agencies of 10–50 people. Features and plans change, so check each vendor's current pages.
Positioning chart. Horizontal axis: how much the tool knows about agency finances, from tasks only to time, budgets and invoicing. Vertical axis: how much setup it needs, from low to high. Productive and Teamwork sit at the finance end with medium setup. ClickUp sits in the middle with high setup. Monday.com and Asana sit at the tasks end with low setup.
A rough map, not a ranking: pick the corner that matches how much you want the tool to know about money.

When to pick an agency-specific tool

Pick Productive or Teamwork when the main problem is that nobody can see whether projects make money until the month is closed. At Square Studio we made Productive.io the hub for projects, CRM and invoicing, with leads captured automatically and invoices generated and filed on their own, which freed more than 50 hours a month and gave the founder capacity to take on more clients.

The trade-off is change: these tools want to run more of the agency, so moving onto one is a bigger project than adding a task board.

When to stay general

Stay with ClickUp, Monday.com or Asana when time and invoicing already work elsewhere and the pain is in how work moves: handoffs, approvals, status. Connecting the tool to your time and finance systems is usually faster than replacing everything. That's what we did at Bandit Studio: Monday.com stayed, and we joined it with the finance data into one view.

If you're choosing between the two most common options, here's ClickUp vs Monday.com for agencies.

Before you switch anything

  1. 1Write down your process first. The stages a project goes through, who approves what, what counts as done.
  2. 2List where data gets typed twice. That list is your real requirement.
  3. 3Trial with one live project, not a demo workspace.
  4. 4Plan the migration as a project, with an owner and a date. Half-migrated is the worst state to be in.

If you'd like help choosing, our Blueprint maps how work and data move through your agency today and recommends what to keep, connect or replace.

— Paul

Want this looked at in your own company?

A free 30-minute call about how work, data and approvals move through your company today.

Find out how many hours you'd get back.

Start with a free 30-minute call. We'll look at how the company runs and tell you honestly where to start: a Blueprint, a rebuild or a one-day workshop.

Scoped on a call, fixed before we start Measured from your own data Two weeks to a ranked roadmap Run online, around your calendar Your tools stay, integrated EU data, by default Scoped on a call, fixed before we start Measured from your own data Two weeks to a ranked roadmap Run online, around your calendar Your tools stay, integrated EU data, by default